Caesars Palace In Times Square? Don’t Bet On It.

New York actual property builders say a on line casino in Manhattan is a protracted shot. Queens and the Bronx are the odds-on favorites—possibly even Coney Island.

John Catsimatidis, the New York Metropolis billionaire finest identified for proudly owning the grocery store chain Gristedes, is on the lookout for the fitting deal to deliver a on line casino to town.

“If it’s the fitting location and the fitting deal, we’re prepared to place up the cash and take part,” Catsimatidis says from his workplace in New York. “After we management a deal, there’s no restrict.”

He says that if he has companions, he can be prepared to place down $200 million, tops, to deliver playing to New York. However there’s one place the 74-year-old Catsimatidis thinks is the worst place to place a on line casino: Manhattan. “The place are you going to place it?” he asks.

The New York State Gaming Fee—which has launched the formal course of to license up to three casinos in and across the metropolis’s 5 boroughs, together with Lengthy Island and Westchester—is predicted to publish a request for proposals no later than January 6, 2023.

However plans for New York casinos have already began to leak early and one which has captured the general public’s creativeness is a proposal for a on line casino within the coronary heart of Manhattan: Caesars Palace Times Square.

Roc Nation, the leisure company based by billionaire music mogul Jay-Z, SL Inexperienced, the New York-based actual property funding belief, and Caesars Leisure are teaming up on a bid to deliver the famed Las Vegas on line casino to New York. The plan is to transform SL Inexperienced’s workplace tower at 1515 Broadway, on the nook of forty fifth Avenue. The businesses declare in the event that they’re in a position to construct a on line casino, purchasing, eating and leisure complicated within the Crossroads of the World, it can deliver hundreds of thousands extra guests to Occasions Sq. each month and entice billions in retail spending and ticket gross sales.

There are additionally different bids for Manhattan. Associated Corporations, the developer behind Hudson Yards in Manhattan and chaired by Stephen Ross, the billionaire proprietor of the Miami Dolphins, announced a plan with Wynn to place a on line casino close to the Javits Middle alongside Manhattan’s West Facet. Stefan Soloviev, the scion of the late Sheldon Solow, who constructed a fortune in Manhattan actual property, can be pitching a casino, full with a Ferris wheel, to be constructed on the unused land he owns close to the United Nations.

MORE FROM FORBESThe Big Gamble: Inside The Battle to Operate A Casino In New York CityBy Will Yakowicz

However the forces of NIMBY, particularly in Occasions Sq., are robust. And one of many neighborhood’s most influential organizations, the Broadway League, a commerce group of producers and theater homeowners, is “firmly in opposition to” playing on the Nice White Manner, Charlotte St. Martin, the affiliation’s president, wrote in a letter to its members in November.

“Whether or not they come for a day or per week, guests to Occasions Sq. come on restricted budgets that might be cannibalized by on line casino playing,” St. Martin wrote. “Each greenback spent on the craps desk, roulette wheel or slot machine is a greenback not spent on a play, dinner, or a memento. That is trigger for alarm.”

The Broadway League, citing a number of research, says a on line casino would create extra congestion, disrupt the native financial system, and cut back security. New York State Senator Brad Hoylman, whose district consists of Occasions Sq. till January 1, says any proposal for Occasions Sq. will face a serious backlash.

“I’ve mentioned it earlier than, and I am going to say it once more, when the Broadway League has drawn a line within the sand on casinos, it is going to be tough to beat,” he says. “Broadway is inextricably linked with Occasions Sq. and vice versa.”

Catsimatidis couldn’t agree extra. He believes the perfect locations to keep away from the highly effective forces of NIMBYism and visitors jams are close to two of New York’s main out of doors stadiums: Within the Bronx, by Yankee Stadium, which has the capability to host “50,000 to 60,000 folks” or CitiField in Queens, house of the Mets, US Open tennis and “a whole lot of wasted land and a whole lot of parking.” Catsimatidis additionally makes a case for the northern shore of Staten Island, which has ferry service from Decrease Manhattan and is accessible by automobile from Brooklyn and New Jersey.

And Catsimatidis shouldn’t be the one developer lengthy on New York’s outer boroughs. Las Vegas Sands, based by the late billionaire and megadonor to the GOP Sheldon Adelson, is not going to submit a proposal for a on line casino in Manhattan, a supply conversant in the corporate’s plans tells Forbes. As a substitute, LVS can be trying on the different 4 boroughs, in addition to Lengthy Island and Westchester. Its superb location can be a giant, multi-acre plot of land accessible by automobile, subway, practice and aircraft.

Steven Cohen, the 66-year-old billionaire hedge fund founder and the proprietor of the New York Mets, has additionally been discussing the potential of growing a on line casino with Onerous Rock close to CitiField in Queens, based on the New York Times.

And actual property developer Thor Equities, which was based by Coney Island native Joe Sitt, simply introduced a $3 billion proposal to deliver a on line casino to America’s Playground. Thor will staff up with Saratoga On line casino Holdings, which owns a racino upstate, the Chickasaw Nation, and Legends, a three way partnership between the New York Yankees and Dallas Cowboys.

Melissa Gliatta, the COO of Thor, says they consider there is just one license obtainable, contemplating the present racinos—Empire in Yonkers and Resorts World in Queens—are prone to get two of the three new licenses. And as for which borough, Thor thinks Manhattan already has sufficient points of interest.“We consider it shouldn’t be Manhattan—it has Broadway and all of the attract,” says Gliatta. “We expect Brooklyn is a profitable location. Why not Brooklyn and why not Coney Island?”

Gliatta says {that a} on line casino in Coney Island may deliver “some actual financial vibrancy” to the neighborhood. Thor owns a giant five-acre swath of land spanning from Surf Avenue to Marvel Wheel Manner and from Stillwell Avenue to West 12^th Avenue.

Catsimatidis, who owns Ocean Drive, a two-tower, 22-story house complicated on the Atlantic Ocean in Coney, says Thor approached him to be a accomplice, however he hasn’t decided but. He provides that Coney Island isn’t precisely superb for a mega-casino; he thinks the world may solely help a smaller, boutique playing venue.

MORE FROM FORBESHow New York Became The Capital Of Mobile BettingBy Will Yakowicz

New York State Senator Joseph Addabbo Jr., chairman of the committee on racing, gaming and wagering, says all the doomsday situations for casinos in New York sound very acquainted.

He remembers all of the opposition earlier than Resorts World opened on the Aqueduct racetrack in 2011. “We had naysayers, worry of the unknown, residents saying they’re shifting if the on line casino comes—these residents are nonetheless there, and 11 years later, Resorts World turned out to be a very good neighbor,” says Addabbo.

Manhattan is “not an insane concept,” he provides, particularly when you consider the state’s essential competitor in terms of playing income: New Jersey.

“They’re very involved a couple of on line casino in Manhattan,” he says. “If one of many concepts is to maintain cash in our state, a few of our thought processes needs to be how will we compete?”

The reply may very well be to place a on line casino as near New Jersey as attainable. However as with every little thing in New York actual property, opening a on line casino in Occasions Sq. will come right down to cash, energy and politics. And proper now, it seems to be like a protracted shot.